Sortable: not working if scrollbar on page (and scrolled down (once?))

This needa a reduced test case - would you be able to provide a test page for us?

I am also experiencing major problems with sortables in a scrolling container.

I made two simple test pages.

The first test with only draggables and droppable area's:

http://pub.romaww.com/jq/testDrop.html

You can drop the draggables to every droppable, thus working fine.

The second test also uses sortable for the droppable area's.

http://pub.romaww.com/jq/testDropSort.html

Now you can only drop a draggable into the sortable drop area's which are visible at the time the handlers are added. If you scroll down first before adding the handlers it gives the same scenario for the area's which are then visible.

The problem not only occurs when using IE7 but also in other browsers (FF3.5, FF3.0, IE8). Using jQuery 1.3.2 and jQuery ui 1.7.2

Adding handlers using this code:

$(".dropArea").droppable({
	drop: function(ev, ui) { $(ui.draggable).html("dropped"); }
});
$(".dropArea").sortable();
$(".dragArea").draggable({
	connectToSortable: '.dropArea',
	revert: 'invalid',
	helper: 'clone'
});

Testcase with 1.8rc2 (thanks Adam): http://jsbin.com/uloya3/8

Reproducable in FF3.6 (not IE specific):

http://jsbin.com/uloya3/12

Scroll down half way, then try to drag one item to the left, twice. The first time, nothing happens. The second time, it'll change the dragged item's text to 'dragged', without actually adding something to the sortable.

Commited visual testcase in r3849.

I can't find any code in draggables or droppables that may be resonposible for handling the scroll offset. Deferring to later release.

Any updates or workarounds on this? Experiencing this problem in 1.8 and it makes ui-sortable useless for longer lists.

Thanks for taking the time to contribute to the jQuery UI project! I can no longer reproduce the issue using the latest jQuery and jQuery UI. http://jsfiddle.net/jxkBn/

If you can still reproduce it, please feel free to reply to this ticket with a test case showing the problem. Thanks!

I am having the same problem. I created a test instance on jsfiddle: http://jsfiddle.net/halm/Fr7hN/1/ It is possible to move items from the 1st list to the 2nd list, unless you scroll down to the bottom of the 2nd list.

In the jsfiddle example above (http://jsfiddle.net/jxkBn), I can break the example if I remove the line "helper: 'clone'" - after that it is possible to *move* the draggables to the top of the droppable list, but not to the bottom of the droppable list. Which sounds like the same problem I am having.

I think I have nailed down where the bug was introduced - in jquery-ui 1.8.12, the following was added to sortable function _refreshPositions:

//We ignore calculating positions of all connected containers when we're not over them
if(item.instance != this.currentContainer && this.currentContainer && item.item[0] != this.currentItem[0])
	continue;

If I put this code into 1.8.11 then it stops working.

I must apologise but I do not have time to work out how to fix this bug as I am already way over budget on this task... but I hope this gives you a headstart.

@halm Your test case indicates that this is likely a duplicate of #7065.

Replying to [comment:17 tj.vantoll]:

@halm Your test case indicates that this is likely a duplicate of #7065.

Agreed, thanks.